Get the differences between fund accounting and commercial accounting today and know what to go with as an accounting student. We’ve shared this knowledge with all students for free.
Students and anyone who aspire to careers in accounting are likely to encounter a wide range of unfamiliar accounting terms. The difference between fund accounting and commercial accounting is one such distinction that can leave many people bewildered. Despite sharing the label of "accounting," there is a vast chasm between the two specializations.
Accounting for monies in a fund is different than regular accounting, and it's utilized by many different types of organizations, including governments and charities. But commercial accounting, often called for-profit accounting, has long been the standard approach for firms to keep track of their money and evaluate how well they're doing.
This blog will go deeply into the worlds of both fund accounting and commercial accounting, comparing and contrasting them as well as highlighting their distinctive qualities. Let's buckle down and figure out the difference between these two types of accounting!
Fund Accounting in a Nutshell
Accounting for funds is a subset of general ledger accounting that is typically employed by government agencies, charities, and other similar organizations. Because they handle the money of others (taxpayers, benefactors, grantors), organizations like these are subject to special accounting regulations. The primary goal of fund accounting is to promote good stewardship of these resources by increasing visibility and responsibility in their administration.
Each fund is treated as a distinct accounting entity in fund accounting, with its own set of accounts, assets, liabilities, revenues, and expenses, and all financial transactions are recorded and reported on an individual basis for each fund. Although they may all be part of the same umbrella organization, each fund is separate and has its own set of goals and procedures. The various types of funds include the General Fund, the Special Revenue Fund, the Capital Projects Fund, and the Enterprise Fund, among others.
Instead of focusing exclusively on financial performance, fund accounting places a strong emphasis on monitoring and reporting on resource utilization. This is because allocating, spending, and reporting on funds is generally subject to stringent rules and regulations in fund accounting. Balance sheets, income statements, and cash flow statements are the most common types of financial statements used in fund accounting.
Commercial Accounting in a Nutshell
Traditional firms use commercial accounting, often called for-profit accounting, to keep track of their financial activities and evaluate how well they're doing. Commercial accounting's major goal is to reveal the financial standing, profitability, and liquidity of a company to its internal and external stakeholders.
The accrual basis of accounting is used in commercial accounting to record and report financial transactions, which means that income is recorded and reported when earned and expenses are recorded and reported when incurred rather than when cash is actually received or paid. In this way, a company's financial success can be more accurately reflected by comparing actual results with projections.
The three main financial statements used in businesses are the income statement, balance sheet, and cash flow statement. Management, investors, lenders, and other stakeholders rely heavily on these statements to get insight into a company's performance, financial situation, and cash flows.
Key Differences Between Fund Accounting and Commercial Accounting
Fund accounting and commercial accounting have some things in common, but there are also significant distinctions between the two. Some key distinctions between the two are as follows:
Purpose:
Accounting for finances is done primarily for the benefit of openness and accountability in the management of other people's money. Commercial accounting, on the other hand, is used to tell both internal and external stakeholders about the company's financial performance, financial condition, and cash flows.
Legal and Regulatory Requirements:
Accountability to taxpayers, donors, and grantees means that government agencies and organizations must adhere to stringent legal and regulatory obligations for fund accounting. Budgeting, spending, and reporting on financial transactions may fall under this category of mandates. Alternatively, commercial accounting is governed by generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) or international financial reporting standards (IFRS), depending on the area or region in which the business operates.
Basis of Accounting:
The modified accrual foundation of accounting is commonly used in the field of fund accounting. This method includes aspects of both cash and accrual accounting. When the resources to pay for an expense or collect revenue are both available and measurable, those transactions are booked as accounting entries. In contrast, commercial accounting operates on the accrual basis of accounting, which means that income and costs are recorded as they are earned or spent rather than waiting for cash to be received or paid before being recorded.
Fund Structure:
Each fund is treated as a unique accounting entity in fund accounting, with its own chart of accounts and set of financial statements. Each fund's assets, liabilities, income, and expenses, as well as its monetary dealings, are tracked and recorded separately. Commercial accounting entails keeping track of all of a company's financial dealings in a consolidated ledger and producing consolidated financial statements.
Reporting Requirements:
When compared to commercial accounting, fund accounting typically calls for increased reporting and disclosure of financial data. This is due to the fact that in the interest of transparency and accountability, government agencies and organizations are frequently forced to provide extensive information regarding the allocation, usage, and reporting of financial resources. Reporting standards in commercial accounting may be less stringent than those in fund accounting, depending on the size and type of organization.
Focus on Performance vs. Compliance:
When it comes to legal and regulatory compliance, as well as reporting on how money was spent, fund accounting excels. There should be a strong focus on checking that money is being used legally and for its intended purpose. Commercial accounting, on the other hand, is more concerned with assessing a company's profitability, liquidity, and other financial indicators so that stakeholders and management can make informed decisions.
Budgeting and Encumbrances:
Fund accounting includes features like budgeting and encumbrances that are absent from commercial accounting. In fund accounting, it is common practice to create individual fund budgets and to encumber or otherwise set aside certain amounts of money from each fund for certain objectives. This is useful for keeping tabs on spending and staying under financial limits. Since businesses have more leeway in how they handle their money, commercial accountants rarely make use of budgeting and encumbrance accounting.
Donor and Grant Restrictions:
Fund accounting is utilized by nonprofits and government agencies because donors and grantors typically have conditions on how their money should be spent. Donor or grant restrictions could limit how the money can be spent and call for unique tracking and reporting. Since most businesses in commercial accounting are supported by equity or debt financing, rather than donations or grants, they have greater leeway in how they spend their money.
Similarities Between Fund Accounting and Commercial Accounting
Fund accounting and commercial accounting are vastly different, yet they do share some common ground. The commonalities between the two are as follows:
Basic Accounting Principles:
Basic accounting principles, such as double-entry bookkeeping, matching, and consistency, form the basis of both fund accounting and commercial accounting. By adhering to these guidelines, financial transactions are properly recorded and reliable financial statements can be generated.
Financial Statements:
As in commercial accounting, financial statements (such as balance sheets, income statements, and cash flow statements) must be compiled in fund accounting as well. Stakeholders can use these statements to gain insight into an organization's financial health, performance, and cash flow.
Auditing:
Financial statements in both fund accounting and commercial accounting must be audited to check for correctness and conformity with requirements. To ensure that the financial statements are trustworthy and free of substantial misstatements, independent auditors perform a crucial role.
Use of Technology:
The automation and streamlining of financial operations have improved both fund accounting and commercial accounting. Software packages like QuickBooks and Xero offer bookkeeping, financial reporting, and analysis features that are useful in both fund accounting and commercial accounting.
Fund Accounting in Nonprofits:
Nonprofits and other charitable organizations often utilize fund accounting because it helps them track the money they receive in the form of donations and grants. Because of the complexity of handling the finances of a nonprofit organization with several funds, each with its own requirements and regulations, fund accounting is an essential tool.
Donations, grants, and other forms of funding for nonprofit organizations can all be recorded in separate accounts to be monitored for proper disbursement. A nonprofit organization's finances may be separated into several distinct funds, such as the general fund, the fundraising fund, the program fund, and the capital projects fund.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) requires certain information regarding a nonprofit's purpose, operations, and finances to be reported annually on Form 990. Fund accounting is a crucial part of nonprofit accounting since Form 990 requires detailed reporting on each fund.
Importance of Fund Accounting for Government Entities
Government agencies also make extensive use of fund accounting, as they frequently create separate funds for various initiatives and activities. A government agency's financial situation, performance, and cash flows must be reported in a document called a Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR).
Accounts can be set up in government accounting to monitor the disbursement of tax and fee revenue according to predetermined guidelines. A government agency, for instance, might keep track of its money in a few different funds: the general fund, the capital projects fund, and the debt payment fund.
Accounting for government finances is vital to ensuring that tax dollars are being used responsibly and in conformity with applicable laws and regulations. Having access to trustworthy financial data is essential for taxpayers and other stakeholders who rely on it to make educated decisions.
Fund Accounting Assignments
Students, especially those who are new to accounting or who are unfamiliar with the nonprofit or government sectors, may find fund accounting to be a difficult subject. Students may be asked to compare and contrast fund accounting with commercial accounting, examine financial statements, or create budgets as part of a fund accounting assignment.
Students who want to do well on fund accounting assignments should begin by reviewing fundamental accounting concepts like double-entry bookkeeping and financial statement production. They should also learn the rules and regulations that govern fund accounting for organizations that serve the public good.
Students may also benefit from using accounting software like QuickBooks or Xero to get experience keeping track of money and creating financial statements. These resources can give students practical experience with fund accounting and shed light on the process of recording and reporting financial transactions.
The bottom line
In conclusion, students contemplating a career in accounting, especially in the nonprofit or government sectors, would do well to familiarize themselves with the distinction between fund accounting and commercial accounting. While both use accounting principles that are similar, they are not the same and have different rules, laws, and goals. Nonprofit and government organizations cannot function without fund accounting, which keeps tabs on money set aside for specific projects and checks for regulatory infractions. Commercial accounting, on the other hand, is used in the for-profit sector to report financial data to investors and customers. Students can better prepare themselves for a career in the nonprofit or government sectors by learning the fundamentals of fund accounting and the regulations that must be met.